Why would my new Pod say NOT to wear Birks?Posted by LouiseR on 4/05/04 at 14:46 (148432)
I've had PF for seven months now and I just recently changed to a new podiatrist. I have a pair of Birkenstock Fulda high-arch sandals that I've been wearing for about a month, but the new podiatrist said I must not wear Birks or any other flat shoe. He told me to buy a pair of 2-inch-heeled Munro 'Joyce' mules. I bought the Munro but haven't had the nerve to wear them yet because they don't seem to have any support, just a wide elastic band that goes over the top of the foot, and about a quarter-inch cushion on a totally smooth footbed. Wouldn't a shoe like that do more damage, especially considering the fact that I overpronate?
I don't know why I'm not allowed to wear the Birks, since so many here say good things about them. He also recommended Brooks Ariel and Merrell Primo, which I also bought and they feel good.
Re: Why would my new Pod say NOT to wear Birks?Ed Davis, DPM on 4/05/04 at 14:48 (148434)
Birks are like a pre-fabricated orthotic -- if the 'hills and valleys' in the Birk fit your foot, they will help; if not, they won't.
Re: Why would my new Pod say NOT to wear Birks?LouiseR on 4/05/04 at 17:55 (148440)
But the Dr didn't even look at how my foot fits the Birks - as soon as he saw me walk into the office wearing them, he said 'never wear Birkenstocks or other flat shoes if you have PF'. I understand why I wouldn't be able to wear any old pair of flats, but with the contoured footbed, the Birks feel really good on my feet. I'm just confused as to why this Dr prefers a Munro mule with seemingly no support over the Birks.
Re: Why would my new Pod say NOT to wear Birks?Ed Davis, DPM on 4/06/04 at 23:34 (148503)
The main purpose of a Munro is to accept an orthotic so it is useful if that is what your doc is making for you. If the Birks feel good on your feet, I would have trouble agreeing with your doc.